Which Notification Template?

Which Notification Template?

I'm having troubles figuring out which notification template is being used behind the Reply button shown in my picture below.
 
The picture is a part of the Requester Conversation.  hctestester1 is the Requester, Tammy is the Technician.
 
hctester1 opens up her request to enter a reply.  She picks and expands the last reply from Tammy the Technician, and clicks on the Reply button located within the conversation.  Which template is that?
 
I have numbered all of the subjects to all of the Request Notification templates (template 1, template 2...) and when hctester1 hits that Reply button, no template number is displayed.  I need to change that template.
 
The Reply button located at the top, under the Description, gives me a numbered template.  I'm good there.
 
Any help would be much appreciated.  Thank you.
 

                  New to ADSelfService Plus?