Certificate Expiry Notification Doesn't Work Properly

Certificate Expiry Notification Doesn't Work Properly

In the SSL certificate section, we keep getting notified by email that a server SSL cert is about to expire even though the certificate for the server has been updated. It keeps showing the wrong cert in the mail. We have removed and rescanned the server several times but the SSL certificate expiry notice email keeps showing the old, expiring in less than 30 days SSL cert.